Clarkson Wright and Jakes Ltd Banner Image

Insights

Family loans in divorce: why formality matters

It is common for parents or other family members to help fund legal fees or living expenses during financial remedy proceedings. However, simply calling money a “loan” does not necessarily mean that a judge will treat it as a genuine liability when considering the appropriate outcome.

In financial remedy proceedings, a distinction is often drawn between “hard” and “soft” loans.

A hard loan is a genuine liability which the borrower is expected to repay and which the lender is likely to enforce. By contrast, a soft loan is typically an informal arrangement where there may be little expectation of repayment or little likelihood that the lender would take steps to recover the money. Loans from close family members are particularly vulnerable to being treated as soft.

The distinction is important because judges may give little or no weight to a soft loan when considering the parties’ respective financial positions and determining an appropriate award. For example, if a parent has advanced £50,000 towards legal fees but there is no written agreement, no interest, no repayment date and no evidence that repayment will actually be required, a judge may decide not to factor that liability into their calculations.

Drafting a robust family loan agreement

Where money is genuinely being lent rather than gifted, we recommend putting a formal written loan agreement in place at the outset. The existence of an agreement cannot determine how the Family Court will ultimately treat the liability, but it can provide important evidence that the parties intended to create a genuine and enforceable obligation to repay.

A properly documented family loan should:

  • be recorded in writing, signed, dated and witnessed;
  • be entered into after the parties have obtained appropriate independent legal advice, with this recorded in the agreement;
  • explain why the lender requires the money to be repaid, for example because it forms part of their retirement or pension provision;
  • provide for a genuine and commercially appropriate rate of interest;
  • require the borrower to keep the lender informed of relevant developments in the financial proceedings and of any final agreement or court order;
  • contain clear repayment provisions, for example repayment within 14 days of receiving a lump sum or completion of the sale of the family home, or within three months of a final financial order; and
  • specify a maximum loan facility, with a running record of the sums actually advanced.

The wider circumstances remain important. A carefully drafted agreement will carry less weight if, in practice, everyone behaves as though repayment will never be required. The parties should therefore ensure that the arrangement reflects a genuine loan not only on paper, but also in how it is operated.

Our recent experience

Our Family and Commercial teams have recently collaborated successfully by drafting, executing and presenting formal commercial loan agreements to the court. The team have had multiple successes in persuading judges that money advanced by a family member was genuinely repayable and should be factored into the court’s assessment, rather than simply being treated as a soft family loan.

The key is to deal with the arrangement properly at the time the money is lent, rather than attempting to formalise or reconstruct it once the financial proceedings are underway. A properly structured and genuinely operated loan provides much stronger evidence of the parties’ intentions and improves the prospects of the liability being given proper weight when the court considers the overall financial outcome.

For advice on documenting family loans in financial remedy proceedings, contact us on 01689 887887 or email sandy.hills@cwj.co.uk

View my profile
    • 01689 887829
    • View profile